Friday, November 20, 2026

Is Your TV Spying on You?

I came across an article that not only is our TVs spying on us (no real surprise), but some of them are doing so by taking screenshots every second or so.

Short form, screenshots probably are not being uploaded to some server on the cloud.

Where this could have affected me is that I use a UHD TV as a monitor for work.  And I handle personal private health information, or PHI, subject to the HIPAA regulations.  Exposure could lead to fines of $100 per data point.  Name, $100, address, another $100, phone number, another $100.  A dataset of 100 people, that's $30,000.  

That is the minimum.  Knowing violations for malicious harm could be 10 years in prison.

So having a screen shot sent to who-knows-where in cyberworld is a problem.

Fortunately for me, I never actually set up the TV to have internet access.  So I am safe there.

But I need to notify the company I work for of that potential, because I am sure there are dual use monitors out there.

The basic system is called Automatic Content Recognition or ACR.  It logs in your watching habits, and any thing like purchases.  The TV Manufacturer then sells that data to data brokers.  That explains somewhat why TV's got so cheap in the last few years. Basic ACR does NOT upload screenshots. But the manufacturers say it is then "Hashed." But it could.  

In one article, 17 companies were asked if they do upload screenshots.  
https://www.theverge.com/tech/1012372/tv-privacy-acr-questions

You can turn off ACR.  But one Northeastern University discovered that Vizio did not honor the turn off switch.

Questions asked include is Audio stored.  Google, LG, Roku, says audio is off by default, but does record audio or transcripts,  Samsung, TCL does not.  Other companies did not answer the question.

On Screenshots collected.  Amazon, Google, LG, Roku, Samsung, no.  Apple, yes, but not by default.
Others did not answer.

Does your TV store of transmit data on watched content.  Amazon, Apple, Google, LG, Samsung, yes
Roku yes, but off by default.  TCL yes, but only for diagnostics.  Others did not answer.

Does the TV identify the location of the owner.  Amazon, Google, LG Roku,, yes. Samsung, TCL, no. Others did not answer.

Does the TV identify demographics of the user (age, gender etc...)  Amazon, Google, LG, TCL, yes.  Samsung, Roku, no. Others did not answer.

Does the TV transmit other devices in the home network. Google, LG, Roku, TCL, yes. Amazon, Samsung no,  Others did not answer.

Can you opt out?  Google, LG, TCL, yes, Amazon, Samsung, Roku, no.  

Is Opt Out the default?  LG, Roku Samsung, yes.  Amazon, Google, TCL no.

If users disconnect a TV from the internet, does the TV store any of these forms of data internally for potential use at a later date?  Amazon, Roku yes.  Google, TCL just crash logs.  LG, no.

Turning off the options is somewhat problematic as the TV manufacturer may have apps installed that also spy.  And internet instructions for specific TV's are at best described as suggestive.




No comments:

Post a Comment